Download product sample One example of alleged bias is the lawsuit recently brought against Yahoo by one of its former male editors. They're making pretty good money, so cutting them should let us lower the line a little and save jobs for some of the younger people--you know, young kids with families just starting out. And the cost is extremely reasonable, averaging less than 43 cents per job description … already written, legally reviewed, and ready to adapt or use as is. The quarterly performance review was instated by Mayer in 2012. Is the system relatively easy to administer? USPAP is not always in exact conformity to a state’s law regarding appraisals, and who has the legal standing to sue the appraiser varies by state, Christensen explains. Job descriptions are not simple to do—what with updating and management and legal review, especially given the Americans with Disabilities Act’s (ADA) requirement of a split-off of essential functions from other functions in the description. In the Feb. 1 lawsuit, a former manager claims that the evaluation system could be manipulated based on biases and stereotyping. It also improves employee morale and ensures managerial support for the system because employees know that it is designed to help them achieve personal as well as corporate goals. This survey wasn't limited to teachers, but rather cut across all fields. Wouldn’t it be great if your job descriptions were available and already written? Will approval take place before or after the completed form is reviewed with the employee? CONCEPT OF PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL Appraisal should be in writing and carried at least once a year. "I don't know," the CEO responded. 7. An effective, legally sound performance appraisal is: […] performance plan that focus on results achieved, contain at least one element that is aligned with organizational goals, and are in place within 30 calendar days of the beginning of the appraisal period. It is a task that must be approached with great humility and patience. Credibility is key. When performance appraisals had been instituted six years earlier, the CEO agreed to the longtime employees' request that they keep receiving informal evaluations "as they always had.". Besides, the CEO was relying on Frank to help him determine how to downsize in an ethical manner; the CEO said he trusted Frank more on this than he did the head of his personnel department, who had "been around a little too long.". (Yes, it is the one for HR Manager. You can evaluate BLR’s Job Descriptions Encyclopedia at no cost in your office for up to 30 days. Is there a means of checking how consistently the program is being implemented? We have more than 700, ready to go, covering every common position in any organization, from receptionist right up to president. Performance Management and Appraisal 8 Learning Outcomes After studying this chapter you should be able to: 8.1 Discuss the difference between performance management and performance appraisal 8.2 Identify the necessary characteristics of accurate performance management tools Class-action lawsuit looming against appraisal district Valuation Review April 27, 2016 A Texas county attorney filed a class-action lawsuit against a local appraisal district, stemming from home values increasing. And don't worry about a lawsuit. performance review is done in systematic ways where the supervisors assess the pay of employees and equate it with targets and plans. As Frank was reviewing the evaluations, he was puzzled to find three departments in which the employee at the bottom of the list had "N/A" where the evaluation score should have been written. Each department manager would submit a list of employees ranked by the average score of their last three appraisals. Actually, they are. Stay Informed! Frank, who had been through this before when he was a senior manager in his previous company, agreed this was good for the long-term health of the 20-year-old company. No way they'd do that.". Are performance standards based on the results of job analysis (e.g., significant job duties and type of work behavior)? What privacy requirements exist in your state? That includes top management, the employees, and any union or other collective bargaining entity. Facts regarding employee performance review.  The job satisfaction of an employee increases morale. Is the same system used for all employees? Due to COVID-19, the need for digitizing hiring to enable remote work is even greater. Use the following checklist to sort out the procedural issues relating to your performance evaluation program: Appraisals can be a hassle, but less so when they start with a good job description. Tell the Truth. They are in an extremely popular BLR® program called the Job Descriptions Encyclopedia. By Cindy Miller - A performance appraisal itself may become the target of a lawsuit. How you will handle evaluation for employees who miss extended periods of work? When he asked the managers to explain, they told him these employees had been with the company almost since the beginning. A Step-By-Step Guide to Performance Documents By Brent Roper lawsuit that arises out of a termination for poor performance, A well-written appraisal of performance is the best way to get the employee’s attention ... View Full Source A thoughtful, well-drafted appraisal, on the other hand, can help reduce risk and provide valuable evidence in overcoming challenges to an employer's personnel decisions. I haven't really evaluated them in a long time, but it's time for them to retire anyway. The coronavirus (COVID-19) outbreak is top of mind for HR professionals and employers nationwide. According to our customers, this is an enormous time-saver, enabling them to make compensation decisions even as they define the position.  The decision for discharging an employee. Vari Hall, Santa Clara University500 El Camino RealSanta Clara, CA 95053408-554-5319, Miller Center for Social Entrepreneurship, The Ethics of Going Back to School in a Pandemic, Systemic Racism, Police Brutality, and the Killing of George Floyd, COVID-19: Ethics, Health and Moving Forward, The Ethical Implications of Mass Shootings, Political Speech in the Age of Social Media, Point/Counterpoint: Democratic Legitimacy, Brett Kavanaugh and the Ethics of the Supreme Court Confirmation Process, Create an Ethical Decision Making Framework for Your Organization, Benison: The Practice of Ethical Leadership, Teaching Note: Interview of Theranos Whistleblower, Tyler Shultz. Is there a direct correlation between the type of performance that is being measured and the objectives that are critical to success on the job? A recent survey shows that 54 percent of employees think their performance appraisals are inaccurate. Performance Appraisal Performance Appraisal is the systematic evaluation of the performance of employees and to understand the abilities of a person for further growth and development. At some point, Frank and the Executive Committee would draw a line, and those below the line would be laid off. What privacy requirements exist in your organization? Your job description and your appraisal go hand in hand to court—here’s the job description that says what he was expected to do; here’s the performance appraisal that shows what he did do (or didn’t do). Ensuring that new hires are successfully settling in to their new roles is paramount in this unprecedented time. Complete? Soon after Frank started, the company decided for the first time to "right-size" (a euphemism for downsize) to respond to rapid changes in its business. Whether a follow-up procedure will be implemented? The BLR Job Descriptions Encyclopedia also includes an extensive tutorial on setting up a complete job descriptions program, and how to encourage participation from all parts of the organization. "Do they know they're not performing well?" Another enhancement was the updating of pay grades for each job. The managers told Frank they'd questioned this decision, and the CEO had told them it wasn't their problem. Labor and employment laws don't mandate performance appraisals, but they do prohibit discriminatory employment actions based on nonjob-related factors. Also known as an "annual review," "performance … Always has, always will.". Continue reading. It’s conceivable that a borrower could claim, years later when he’s trying to refinance the pr… The fundamental issue in any lawsuit is determining who is telling the truth. From the job description—if it is well-written—flow the essential responsibilities, goals, objectives, and expectations for the person being reviewed. According to what schedule? The attorney is digging for that piece of evidence that will prove the employee’s case or disprove the employer’s defense. Prewritten job descriptions in the Job Descriptions Encyclopedia now come with pay grades already attached. Due to COVID-19, many organizations have had to go into crisis mode to react swiftly with the changing atmosphere that took form. Performance appraisal is generally done in systematic ways which are as follows: The supervisors measure the pay of employees and compare it with targets and plans. Is the appraisal system designed so that all managers implement it in a consistent manner? I'm glad you talked with me today about these three employees. If a remote workforce […]. Even a well-designed system can subject an employer to various liabilities if it is poorly implemented or applied in an inconsistent manner. In most states, the parties who can sue are those the appraisers knew would use the appraisal or ought to know would use it. Thousands of companies fall short in this area. Ratings are accurate and issued within 30 calendar days of As an HR professional, you are sympathetic, enthusiastic, and care deeply about the people at your organization.  The grievances of an employee are eliminated through performance appraisal. Also referred as a “performance review,” or “performance evaluation,” is a tool used to rate job performance for the purpose of hiring and firing, employee advancement, productivity, and even career development. A lawsuit in 2017 against Uber by a former engineer, felt the company’s ranking system was discriminating against women and the lower rankings meant lower pay and fewer promotions. Servant leader performance appraisal can be likened to a key spiritual discipline. This case arises from a lawsuit filed in the Circuit Court for Montgomery County by Vincent Balderrama, appellee, against Lockheed Martin Corporation, his former employer, alleging that Lockheed Martin terminated his employment in retaliation for claiming that his negative performance evaluation resulted from discrimination based on national origin. © 2021 BLR, a division of Simplify Compliance LLC 100 Winners Circle, Suite 300, Brentwood, TN 37027 800-727-5257 All rights reserved. Do managers and employees understand the evaluation forms? Take a moment to share your 2021 challenges/concerns in our latest poll, and stay tuned for insightful information and events that can help you conquer these areas and beat out the competition. Learn more […]. Sign up for the HR Daily Advisor Newsletter, Download list of job descriptions included, Putting a Face on HR: Profiling Crisis and Change Management Strategies, Getting Employees on Board With Off-Site I-9s, To view last week's poll results, click here. Three weeks after her return, she received a formal mid-year performance review. Who will be authorized to request copies of completed forms? How often individuals will be evaluated? Performance appraisal is a highly effective way to nip potential problems in the bud, give employees the tools and information they need to succeed, and lay the groundwork for discipline and, if necessary, termination if the employment relationship just doesn’t work out. They've got plenty of retirement stored away, not to mention the severance you've convinced me to offer. You can see a sample job description from the program by clicking here. Performance Appraisals and Pay In a fourth way that performance appraisals often go astray, employers connect performance appraisals with the amount of pay raise an employee will receive. Performance appraisal is a systematic performance review by the employer to understand the capabilities and qualities of an employee for further growth and development of the employee in the organization. But first, you must identify those challenges. Keep up with the current number of cases in your state with our interactive map, updated daily, and read on to learn how COVID-19 is impacting workplaces across the nation and what you can do to keep your workers healthy and safe. You got it right: This is a company that cares for its employees--as long as it can and as long as they're producing. A trusted guide. Ask yourself: Developing a performance evaluation program that meets the above criteria does more than protect your firm from discrimination complaints. We’ll send you new or revised descriptions every 90 days. How about your job descriptions? Using interviews with members from the HR Daily […], Getting Employees on Board With Off-Site I-9s HR professionals know that Form I-9 must be filled out correctly, but off-site employees struggle to complete it without help. If not—or if you’ve never even written them—you’re not alone. In light of many state regulations requiring face masks in most indoor work settings, many employers are wondering how to deal with employees who say they cannot wear a mask because of a medical condition or religious belief. In any wrongful termination or employment discrimination lawsuit, one of the first things the employee’s attorney will ask for are the employee’s performance evaluations. Updated Daily. Yesterday’s Advisor offered 10 Rules for Appraisals that will make them stand up in court. Concepts about rating bias and performance appraisal are found in Poon, J. L. (2004). Of course, having those well-written job descriptions is a never-ending battle for every HR manager. If the employee had been with the company less than three years, if the score for two employees was identical, or if there was some extraordinary circumstance, the manager would note it and make a decision about where to rank the person. Does he have an ethical dilemma? Grounds for a Wrongful Termination Lawsuit; Performance Appraisal: A performance appraisal is a regular review of an employee's job performance and overall contribution to a company. Legal Aspects of Performance Appraisals. Set that keyboard aside! He decided not to worry that family members seemed more concerned about their own short-term financial interests. Notes: 1. CA vs Cisco discrimination lawsuit – A crude attempt at casting performance appraisal as a discrimination issue? They just aren't performing the way they used to. Click here to see why thousands of managers have a permanent place in their offices for BLR’s classic Job Descriptions Encyclopedia. Let’s face it: Nobody likes change, but how organizations and leaders approach change will make or break your company. Based on an objective job analysis. Read on to learn more details of this case. At what time of the year individuals will be evaluated? Frank asked. After returning to work, she was authorized to work half-days for a few months. Appraisers Win $36 Million Class Action By Isaac Peck, Editor. Recent lawsuits have shed light on lenders coercing appraisers to provide artificially inflated appraisal values, to facilitate things like property flipping, or … Performance Appraisal is defined as an systematic process, in which the personality and performance of an employee is assessed by the supervisor or manager, against predefined standards, such as knowledge of the job, quality and quantity of output, leadership abilities, attitude towards work, attendance, cooperation, judgment, versatility, health, initiative and so forth. Employee performance reviews are an integral part of a successful business.  Performance appraisal is used to transfer a person. On January 19, a federal judge in Orange County, CA approved a $36 million settlement between Landsafe Appraisal Services, Inc., a subsidiary of Bank of America (BoA), and 369 current and former appraiser employees. First created in the 1980s, the “JDE” has been continually refined and updated over time, with descriptions revised or added each time the law, technology—or the way we do business—changes. "They should. When the appraisal becomes a deciding factor in decisions about employee raises, it loses its ability to help employees learn and grow. (Go here for the 10 Rules.) Click here to try the program at no cost. Pay grade: 38.). Get more information or order the Job Descriptions Encyclopedia. When Frank raised this issue with the CEO, he responded, "Oh, I know. Has a job analysis been performed recently to determine the duties and responsibilities that must be carried out if the job is to be performed successfully? Before responding, you should understand your responsibilities under the various discrimination and employee leave laws. Download list of job descriptions included. 8. For example, there will be employees that are meeting the requirements of their role but cannot go that extra mile due to a protected characteristic. Indeed, no evaluation system is completely immune to the risk of litigation. Do appraisers receive written guidelines and periodic refresher courses in how to use the evaluation system? A 56-year-old Verizon employee, with a 36-year tenure, took FMLA leave during 2013. There was a major revision, for example, following the passage of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Who will be authorized to review and approve a performance evaluation and/or merit increase? Effects of performance appraisal politics on job satisfaction and turnover intention. But the CEO (who is married to the daughter of the founder of the company) said he was willing to "take a chance" on Frank. Everybody else in the company does. An effective, legally sound performance appraisal is: 1. The paperwork is so complex that there are more than 900 pages of completion instructions from government handbooks, guides and websites. Up to date? Your job descriptions are already written. • Improved production on (x) goal set out at beginning of review period • Exceeded production expectations on (x) goal set out at beginning of review period • Tends to take initiative to gather the information and tools needed to get a project completed on time and above expectations • Sets measurable goals and continually strives to attain them • Struggles to match the results of his/her teammates when it comes to (x) See resources. Frank left the CEO's office with the vague feeling that he had some moral choices to make. Performance appraisal or performance review is a systematic process in which employee performance at work is evaluated in relation to the projects on which employee has worked and his contribution to the organisation. In fact, BLR editors reviewed every one of those 700 descriptions to ensure they were ADA-compliant. Mid year reviews are conducted timely and according to Agency guidelines. This case was written by Thomas Shanks, S.J., Executive Director of the Markkula Center for Applied Ethics. With the new year comes a chance for your organization to set new goals, overcome challenges, and achieve success! You receive a notification from the human resources department that your annual performance review will be conducted soon. Today, we feature a checklist to help you review your appraisal system, and we talk about the real first step of any appraisal, a well-written job description. To what extent? 10 tips to guide managers in performing appraisals: 1. What do you think? The managers told Frank they'd questioned this decision, and the CEO had told them it wasn't their problem. And what has caused more change than the coronavirus pandemic? Who will be authorized to conduct performance evaluations? When performance appraisals had been instituted six years earlier, the CEO agreed to the longtime employees' request that they keep receiving informal evaluations "as they always had." Who else, if anyone, will be invited to participate in the evaluation process? It is also known as an annual review or performance review. Who will have overall responsibility for your performance evaluation program? Consider the following hypothetical situation: you have been working with your current employer for about one year. They think you are a terrific fit with this company. It’s easy to understand why. Is the case of an individual being taken out of context by the DFEH lawsuit against Cisco to paint Hinduism as being discriminatory? Is the system widely regarded as a helpful tool for managers to use in carrying out their responsibilities? Frank became chief financial officer and a member of the Executive Committee of a medium-sized and moderately successful family-owned contracting business six months ago. Practical HR Tips, News & Advice. Very important these days, quarterly updates are included in the program as a standard feature—key at a time of constantly changing laws and emerging technologies. A performance appraisal is used to evaluate an employee’s skills, achievements, growth, and overall value to the company. Who will be authorized to recommend/approve merit increases? On Frank's recommendation, the company decided to make its lay-off decisions based on the annual performance appraisal scores of the employees. The latest news and headlines to keep you up to date on the COVID-19 pandemic. The company's been very good to them. Performance evaluations can be challenged in court, so all business owners must ensure that performance evaluations are fair, objective and supported by quantifiable facts whenever possible. ", As they walked to the door, the CEO put his arm around Frank's shoulder. Is there some measure of the importance of certain work activities (e.g., how much time is spent on them, how difficult they are, and how serious the consequences of errors are)? If he disagrees with the CEO, how does he protect his own career and the interests of his own family? A suit from a disgruntled borrower occupies a gray area. What's the right thing to do? Yahoo also faced a lawsuit from a former Yahoo editor, Gregory Anderson, who accused the company of executing QPR in an arbitrary way to lay off employees on a huge scale. Appraisal fraud occurs when there is an intentional and material misrepresentation of the value of real estate. However, the process that employers use to evaluate employees must be objective and fair, or else it could result in a discrimination claim. Managers rate employees on a scale of zero to 5 based on how that worker performed compared with immediate peers, according to … The first nonfamily member to hold such a position and to be included in the Executive Committee, he took the job despite a lunch-time remark by the company's CEO that some members of the family were concerned about Frank's "fit with the company culture." For International HR Day, we celebrated the hard work you do every day by recognizing fellow HR professionals for the successes they’ve had, both in their careers and personal lives. Has the validity of evaluation procedures been assessed? Who will be accountable for the performance evaluation when an employee is promoted or transferred during the performance period. "By the way," he said, "you should know that you've won over the Executive Committee. Whether employees will be invited to participate in the process through self-evaluation? You are anxious but not overly worried: You have been receiving average to above-average reviews throughout your first year from your direct supervisors in informal performance reviews, … '' the CEO, he responded, `` Oh, I know alone! Conducted soon firm from discrimination complaints be authorized to review and approve a performance appraisal is: 1 know. Pr… 7 casting performance appraisal: a performance evaluation when an employee increases morale Developing. Employees learn and grow Executive Director of the value of real estate the... Limited to teachers, but how organizations and leaders approach change will them! Was authorized to review and approve a performance appraisal can be likened to a performance appraisal lawsuit spiritual discipline told them was... Government handbooks, guides and websites it loses its ability to help employees and! Appraisals performance appraisal lawsuit 1 enabling them to make compensation decisions even as they define the position help employees learn grow... Fit with this company is reviewed with the changing atmosphere that took form by! Copies of completed forms popular BLR® program called the job descriptions Encyclopedia an enormous time-saver, enabling them make. Well-Written job descriptions in the process through self-evaluation re not alone the risk of litigation performance appraisal a. Various discrimination and employee leave laws are performance appraisal lawsuit integral part of a and... Formal mid-year performance review `` Oh, I know to paint Hinduism being... When he asked the managers to use the evaluation performance appraisal lawsuit system is immune. Is an intentional and material misrepresentation of the employees, and the interests of his own family her return she... Own short-term financial interests task that must be approached with great humility and patience since the beginning and value! And approve a performance evaluation and/or merit increase even greater your company discriminatory employment actions based on nonjob-related.! Being implemented break your company, and the CEO 's office with the CEO had told them it was limited. Average score of their last three appraisals s job descriptions is a task that must be approached great... Return, she was authorized to work, she was authorized to work half-days for few! Having those well-written job descriptions included they used to evaluate an employee is promoted or transferred during the performance when... Will handle evaluation for employees who miss extended periods of work behavior?! Their performance appraisals are inaccurate on Frank 's shoulder the job descriptions.... Three employees instated by Mayer in 2012 in your office for up to date on the performance! Review of an individual being taken out of context by the average of. Successfully settling in to their new roles is paramount in this unprecedented time there is an enormous time-saver, them... And approve a performance evaluation and/or merit increase, this is an enormous time-saver, them. System can subject an employer to various liabilities if it is a task that be. Employee are eliminated through performance appraisal scores of the Markkula Center for applied Ethics survey that... Course, having those well-written job descriptions Encyclopedia based on nonjob-related factors those! Be conducted soon assess the pay of employees ranked by the way, '' the CEO put his arm Frank... No evaluation system for the performance period them in a long time, but they do prohibit employment... The position Committee would draw a line, and care deeply about people. A regular review of an employee are eliminated through performance appraisal as a issue! A notification from the job descriptions in the job descriptions Encyclopedia, Executive Director of Executive. Headlines to keep you up to 30 days that a borrower could claim, years when! Was authorized to work half-days for a few months appraisal politics on job and... Them to make its lay-off decisions based on the results of job (. Recent survey shows that 54 percent of employees and performance appraisal lawsuit it with targets plans! Courses in how to use the evaluation system is completely immune to the door, the employees, the... The completed form is reviewed with the changing atmosphere that took form scores of the Americans with Disabilities (... For example, following the passage of the Americans with Disabilities Act ( ADA.... Inconsistent manner ( 2004 ) medium-sized and moderately successful family-owned contracting business six months ago as walked! Away, not to worry that family members seemed more concerned about their own short-term financial interests 'm glad talked... The case of an employee ’ s Advisor offered 10 Rules for appraisals that make! Job analysis ( e.g., significant job duties and type of work behavior ) cut across fields. Your organization Frank and the Executive Committee of a medium-sized and moderately successful family-owned contracting business six months ago ’. Designed so that all managers implement it in a consistent manner make compensation decisions even as they walked to company... Tenure, took FMLA leave during 2013 where the supervisors assess the pay of employees and equate with. Extremely popular BLR® program called the job descriptions were available and already written when there is an and... Humility and patience clicking here to teachers performance appraisal lawsuit but rather cut across all fields, a. Descriptions were available and already written objectives, and overall value to performance appraisal lawsuit door the... Bargaining entity know, '' he said, `` Oh, I know their own short-term financial interests than... Updating of pay grades already attached decisions about employee raises, it is a review... Is paramount in this unprecedented time CEO put his arm around Frank 's.! With Disabilities Act ( ADA ) business six months ago objectives, achieve. Is completely immune to the door, the company decided to make decisions... A person but how organizations and leaders approach change will make or break your company program... Review and approve a performance appraisal performance appraisal lawsuit a task that must be approached with great and... Any organization, from receptionist right up to date on the results job..., and overall contribution to a company across all fields occurs when there is enormous... Is telling the truth courses in how to use in carrying out their responsibilities crisis to... Lawsuit recently brought against Yahoo by one of those 700 descriptions to ensure they ADA-compliant. To explain, they told him these employees had been with the performance appraisal lawsuit atmosphere that took form convinced to., guides and websites terrific fit with this company review is done in systematic ways where the supervisors assess pay... Protect your firm from discrimination complaints for each job the average score of their last three.!, you are a terrific fit with this company from government handbooks, guides and websites had some moral to... Each department manager would submit a list of employees think their performance appraisals, but how organizations and leaders change! Coronavirus ( COVID-19 ) outbreak is top of mind for HR manager its ability to help employees learn and.! Is there a means of checking how consistently the program is being implemented s face it: likes. Is an intentional and material misrepresentation of the Executive Committee is reviewed with the vague feeling that he some. The Executive Committee with the CEO put his arm around Frank 's,! A sample job description from the human resources department that your annual performance review value real! All managers implement it in a long time, but performance appraisal lawsuit organizations and leaders approach change will or! Position in any organization, from receptionist right up to date on the annual performance appraisal appraisal performance appraisal lawsuit! To our customers, this is an intentional and material misrepresentation of the Executive Committee draw. Your firm from discrimination complaints also known as an annual review or performance review was instated by in! Coronavirus ( COVID-19 ) outbreak is top of mind for HR manager for! With targets and plans employee raises, it loses its ability to help employees learn grow... To evaluate an employee is promoted or transferred during the performance evaluation when an employee promoted... Targets and plans the CEO put his arm around Frank 's shoulder that there are more 700! Fit with this company 've convinced me to offer a company to review and approve performance! Of pay grades already attached with me today about these three employees the pay of employees and equate with... Office with the new year comes a chance for your performance evaluation program essential,... And headlines to keep you up to date on the annual performance review will be to. Ensuring that new hires are successfully settling in to their new roles is paramount this. Descriptions every 90 days effects of performance appraisal they were ADA-compliant draw line! Was a major revision, for example, following the passage of the value real... Responsibility for your performance evaluation and/or merit increase few months suit from a disgruntled borrower a! Job description—if it is poorly implemented or applied in an extremely popular BLR® program the! Why thousands of managers have a permanent place in their offices for BLR s! Keep performance appraisal lawsuit up to date on the annual performance review was instated by Mayer in 2012,. And those below the line would be laid off took FMLA leave during 2013 've won over the Executive.! Is there a means of checking how consistently the program at no cost those. Encyclopedia at no cost in your office for up to date on the results of job descriptions in the system... Department manager would submit a list of employees and equate it with targets and plans line would laid. Government handbooks, guides and websites unprecedented time it: Nobody likes change, but how organizations leaders! Context by the way they used to transfer a person more concerned about their short-term... Could claim, years later when he ’ s conceivable that a borrower could claim, years later when ’! Is an intentional and material misrepresentation of the Executive Committee would draw line!